The Leading Independent Resource for Top-tier MBA Candidates
Menu


Home » News » News » Clear Admit's MBA Ranking News » DecisionWire Data Suggests a Tiered Business School Ranking

DecisionWire Data Suggests a Tiered Business School Ranking

tiered business school ranking

As many of our readers know, U.S. News & World Report is scheduled to release its annual ranking of leading MBA programs next week. We wanted to use this time—ahead of the ranking’s release—to highlight some key insights from our MBA DecisionWire data, which we think will provide context for the upcoming rankings and perhaps even foretell some of the results.

Our analysis of DecisionWire data yielded some fascinating findings that we believe support a tiered ranking system for schools, one in which the peer group a school finds itself in serves as a better indicator of program quality than a school’s ordinal ranking. As always, with MBA DecisionWire, we preface our analysis with a reminder that we’re still dealing with a relatively modest sample size. Of course, the more of you who upload your results, the better MBA DecisionWire and these analyses will become.

“With this analysis, we are delighted to see MBA DecisionWire’s multiple benefits emerge,” says Graham Richmond, Clear Admit co-founder. “In addition to providing applicants with a fantastic platform for sharing admissions results and assisting one another in making enrollment decisions, DecisionWire has also furnished a wealth of valuable data. And as we dig into that data, we find increasing evidence to support the grouping of schools into tiers rather than in a more traditional, ordinal ranking.”

What We Did: Identify Cross Admits, Establish Peer Groups

This exercise was very straightforward. We examined 16 of the leading MBA programs in the United States, identifying each program’s most common “cross-admit” schools. Cross-admit schools are pairs of schools at which an applicant who applied to and was admitted to one also applied to and was admitted to the other. Below, we have listed each school’s top six cross-admit schools in order of overlap and then analyzed whether and how cross-admit data supports our proposed tiered ranking system of schools.

When identifying the six most common cross admits for each school, we based our calculations on the percentage of a school’s admits, rather than the raw number. The results are presented below.

MBA DecisionWire Cross Admits

(In Order of Percentage of Shared Admits)

MAGNIFICENT 7

The Magnificent 7 schools are listed below in bold in alphabetical order in the left-hand column. Each school’s corresponding cross-admit schools are listed in the right-hand column, in order of percentage of shared admits.

Chicago BoothWharton, MIT, Kellogg, Columbia, tie: Harvard and Tuck
Columbia Business SchoolWharton, MIT, tie Stern and Chicago, Yale, Stanford
Harvard Business SchoolStanford, Wharton, MIT, Kellogg, tie: Chicago and Tuck
Kellogg School of ManagementHaas, Chicago, Harvard, Tuck, Ross, Wharton
MIT SloanWharton, Stanford, Columbia, Chicago, tie: Harvard and Haas
Stanford GSBHarvard, MIT, Haas, Yale, Wharton, Columbia
Wharton SchoolMIT, Chicago, Harvard, Columbia, Stanford, Stern


Key Takeaway
:
For the above seven schools, commonly referred to as the Magnificent 7 or M7, all except Kellogg count four or more other M7 schools among their cross-admit schools. Additionally, all schools count either Harvard and Wharton, Harvard and Stanford or Stanford and Wharton as peer schools, and some count all three.

 

FAB FOUR

The Fab Four schools are listed below in bold in alphabetical order in the left-hand column. Each school’s corresponding cross-admit schools are listed in the right-hand column, in order of percentage of shared admits.

Berkeley HaasKellogg, tie: Anderson and Marshall, Stanford, Harvard, MIT
Dartmouth TuckDarden, Yale, Duke, tie: Cornell and Ross, Kellogg
NYU SternYale, Columbia, Wharton, tie: Anderson and Haas, Chicago
Yale SOMStern, Stanford, Tuck, MIT, Haas, tie: Columbia and Duke


Key Takeaway:
For the above four schools—which we would argue constitute the tier below the M7 schools—only Haas counts more than one of the Harvard, Stanford, Wharton trinity as a peer school. Where Haas has four M7 schools as peer schools, Tuck has only one. What distinguishes this group from the next tier is that none of the schools has a peer school that is outside of the 16 schools in our broad analysis.

 

FANTASTIC FIVE

The Fantastic Five schools are listed below in bold in alphabetical order in the left-hand column. Each school’s corresponding cross-admit schools are listed in the right-hand column, in order of percentage of shared admits.

Cornell JohnsonDuke, tie: Kenan Flagler and Tepper, tie; Georgetown and Darden, Tuck
Duke FuquaRoss, Cornell, tie Darden and Kenan Flagler, Tuck, Yale
Michigan RossDuke, Darden, Tuck, Cornell, Georgetown, Tepper
UCLA AndersonMarshall, Haas, Ross, Stern, Duke, Cornell
UVA DardenKenan Flagler, Tuck, Tepper, Duke, Ross, Cornell


Key Takeaway:
For schools within this tier, none lists an M7 school as a peer and each includes at least one peer school from a tier below the tiers we have listed.

This analysis of DecisionWire data is incredibly helpful in terms of framing the peer groups and tiers that exist within the very best American business schools. “We have advocated a tiered ranking system now for some time, and I think this data helps support that idea,” says Clear Admit’s Alex Brown. “As we draw even more entries on DecisionWire, we will be able to further test the data and its support of the proposed tiers.” Notably, Berkeley’s Haas School of Business proved the most surprising program in this initial analysis. “Our data suggests it’s almost comparable with some of the group of M7 schools,” Brown adds.

Stay tuned for additional analysis of DecisionWire data, as well as complete coverage of the 2017 U.S. News & World Report business school rankings, due out March 14th. As always, those of us here at Clear Admit encourage prospective applicants to use rankings as just one of many means of evaluating target business schools.

Posted in: Clear Admit's MBA Ranking News, DecisionWire, MBA News, News

Schools: Berkeley / Haas, Columbia, Cornell / Johnson, Dartmouth / Tuck, Duke / Fuqua, Harvard Business School, Michigan / Ross, MIT Sloan, Northwestern / Kellogg, NYU Stern, Stanford GSB, U. Chicago Booth, UCLA Anderson, UPenn / Wharton, UVA / Darden, Yale SOM

About the Author

Clear Admit
Clear Admit

The leading resource for top-tier MBA candidates.

[jetpack-related-posts]
  • Sign Up For Our Newsletter

    Expert admissions advice and the latest news on top business schools delivered straight to your inbox.
  • Join the Clear Admit community for free and conduct unlimited searches of MBA LiveWire, MBA DecisionWire, MBA ApplyWire and the Interview Archive. Register now and you’ll also get 10% off your entire first order.

    Click here to register!

    Already have an account? .

    Log In

    Please enter your Username and Password

    Don’t have an account? Register for free